TOPIA: Canadian Journal of Cultural Studies
Published biannually | E-ISSN 1916-0194 | ISSN 1916-0194
This Journal is online at:
Lily Cho, York University
Eve Haque, York University
Rinaldo Walcott, University of Toronto
Book Review Editor
Alexandra Boutros, Wilfrid Laurier University
Jody Berland, York University
Alexandra Boutros, Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada
Jenny Burman, McGill University, Canada
Greig de Peuter, Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada
OmiSoore H Dryden, Thorneloe University at Laurentian, Canada
Bob Hanke, York University, Canada
Eve Haque, York University, Canada
Alison Hearn, University of Western Ontario, Canada
Daniel McNeil, Carleton University, Canada
Kirsty Robertson, University of Western Ontario, Canada
Sharon Sliwinski, University of Western Ontario, Canada
Miglena Todorova, University of Toronto, Canada
Ien Ang, University of Western Sydney, Australia
Ian Angus, Simon Fraser University, Canada
Susan Ashley, Northumbria University, United Kingdom
Bruce Barber, Nova Scotia College of Art & Design, Canada
Darin Barney, McGill University, Canada
Sirma Bilge, Université de Montréal, Canada
Andrew Burke, University of Winnipeg, Canada
Greg Elmer, Ryerson University, Canada
Andrea Fatona, OCAD University, Canada
Matthew Flisfeder, University of Winnipeg, Canada
Murray Forman, Northeastern University, United States
Gary Genosko, University of Ontario Institute of Technology, Canada
Noreen Golfman, Memorial University of Newfoundland, Canada
Line Grenier, Université de Montréal, Canada
Peter James Hudson, University of California, Los Angeles, United States
Penelope Ironstone, Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada
Naila Keleta-Mae, University of Waterloo, Canada
Peter Kulchyski, University of Manitoba, Canada
Darryl Leroux, St. Mary's University, Canada
Gada Mahrouse, Concordia University, Canada
Sara Matthews, Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada
Katherine McKittrick, Queen's University, Canada
Elizabeth Philipose, California State University, Long Beach, United States
Christine Ramsay, University of Regina, Canada
Trish Salah, Queen's University, Canada
Malinda S. Smith, University of Alberta, Canada
Jonathan Sterne, McGill University, Canada
Will Straw, McGill University, Canada
Pauline Wakeham, University of Western Ontario, Canada
Anne Whitelaw, Concordia University, Canada
TOPIA: Canadian Journal of Cultural Studies
University of Toronto
12-227, 252 Bloor Street West
Toronto, Ontario M5S 1V6
Open Access Policy
In response to the Tri-Agency Open Access Policy on Publications, TOPIA has developed a plan to ensure our authors are able to comply with the policy.
Green Open Access
Twelve (12) months after publication of the version of record (i.e., the article after copyediting, tagging, typesetting, etc.), the author may deposit a copy of the accepted article in their institutional repository with a DOI or direct link to the version of record. Please let us know when the deposit is made so that we can update our records.
Abstracting and indexingArticles appearing in this journal are abstracted and indexed in Contemporary Culture Index, International Bibliography of the Social Sciences, Historical Abstracts, America: History and Life, Canadian Reference Centre (EBSCO), Academic Search Premier, Ulrich’s Periodicals Directory, Canadian Business and Current Affairs Database (CBCA), OCLC, Journal-Seek, Gale Licensing, and Thomson Reuters (Web of Science).
TOPIA: Canadian Journal of Cultural Studies is Canada's leading academic peer-reviewed cultural journal. We have published bi-annually since launching in 1997.
TOPIA uses an online peer-review system called ScholarOne Manuscripts where authors, peer reviewers, and book reviewers can submit articles, evaluations, and book reviews online. From initial submissions to final acceptance, ScholarOne Manuscripts streamlines the publication process to make it easy and effective for authors, reviewers, and editors alike. When your article is ready for submission, please submit it through the ScholarOne Manuscripts interface.
TOPIA uses a double-blind peer-review process.
Blinding a manuscript entails removing all references to your name and publications, and to the setting and participants in your research, where relevant. Appropriately blinding your manuscript requires that you replace your name (and any co-author’s names), wherever it occurs in the text, notes or references, with the word “Author.”
“Author” is then inserted into the reference list with the other “A” references. Do not insert “Author” references alphabetically with the letter that corresponds to your last name. When blinding the context of your research, use pseudonyms for the names of institutions or participants, and do not identify the city or town in which the research took place if it could serve to identify the participants and/or the institution. For example, “a bilingual university in Ottawa” is inadequate blinding because there is only one such university. Try to avoid including any other characteristics that might lead to the identification of the individuals or institutions involved.
Please also remove any information that would identify you from the “Properties” section of your Word file.
Manuscripts that have not been blinded will be returned to the authors for blinding before they are sent out to the reviewers, which delays the publication process. If the article is accepted for publication, authors must restore all personal information and references to their article.
Prior to submitting your article, you will have to register through the TOPIA online peerreview system ScholarOne Manuscripts. You will be submitting your final manuscript as a Word document by using ScholarOne Manuscripts.
In addition to scholarly articles on cultural studies, TOPIA publishes book reviews and visual-culture review. Please send any enquiries to: firstname.lastname@example.org
After you submit your article, the article will be peer-reviewed by qualified academics in the field. Based on this evaluation, you will receive one of the following responses: accepted as is, rejected, or returned for further revisions. This is a process that can take weeks or months; please be patient.
Upon initial submission, all supporting files including figures and illustrations, tables, and images must be submitted within the text. Once the manuscript is accepted for publication please use the phrase, “Figure 1 about here” in the approximate places where your table or figure should appear in the final copy of the manuscript and submit your figures as supplementary files with the correct specifications on ScholarOne Manuscripts.
The final revised manuscript – in a Word document – should be double-spaced, in a 12-point font, and must have a complete bibliography of all sources cited. Ensure the word count is below 10,000.
Subheadings should be in bold typeface.
Except in the most obvious instances, avoid abbreviations.
Use only one space after a period, colon, semicolon, and comma. Use an en dash for date and page ranges, and an em dash (without spaces on either side of it) as an interrupter. Refer to the Chicago Manual of Style (latest edition) for further grammatical guidance. Avoid pagelayout formatting. The text should be aligned flush left and ragged right; do not justify or centre.
Please do not include any running headers or footers but do insert page numbers. Use Microsoft Word’s line-numbering feature (under the Page Layout tab in Office 2010, 2013) so that reviewers can easily reference your work.
If you are writing a book or exhibition review, please limit your word count to 2,000 words. It should be formatted as below:
Title of the Review
A review of
By (Edited by) Author’s First and Last Name OR Editor’s First Name and Last Name, Year of publication, Title, City (or Cities): Publisher.
All sources must be written according to the latest edition of the Chicago Manual of Style.
Use endnotes, not footnotes, by using the automated feature in Word, which will place superscript numbers, for endnote references, in the main body of the article and then allow you to type your notes at the end of your text. Please add the heading NOTES to this section. Follow the directions for citations in endnotes in The Chicago Manual of Style.
References to a previously cited work require only the author’s last name and relevant page number(s). Include the title of the work only if more than one work by the same author is cited in the notes. Do not use ‘op. cit.’ Use shortened citations instead of ibid.
Use author-date system as outlined in the Chicago Manual of Style, latest edition
(Smith 1989, 221).
(Smith 1989, 221–248; see also Jones 2001).
(as found in Ray 2003, 305, n. 17).
(Smith and Jones 1996, 44, nn. 12–13).
(Smith et al. 2001; White 1998, 2000).
(Unattributed book title 1996, 213–214, emphasis added).
(Smith et al. 1999, 302, 305).
(see Kennell 2003, 198–202; 2004, 336–341; 2005, 290–293; Rupp 2006, 207–211; 2007, 134–136; 2008, 246–249; 2009, 111–114; 2011, 16–20).
- Periods ending a sentence are placed outside final parenthesis.
- References following an indented quote: indented block quote, when quotation longer than 40 words. (Brown 1996, 278).
- Multiple references in the text: cite alphabetically, separated with a semi-colon (Bryant 1995; Reich 1992).
- When referring to multiple references of a single author: cite in order of years, separated by a comma (Bryant 1995, 2000).
- Immediate subsequent references to single publication: provide page numbers only.
- For multiple texts by single authors, repeat author’s name and date for each reference.
- Cite original sources as much as possible. When citing a quote reproduced in another author’s work, use “quoted in,” not “qtd. in” (Hecker quoted in Brown 1996, 278).
- Avoid Latin abbreviated forms where possible, eg. “idem”, “passim” etc.
Interviews and Personal Communication
Unpublished interviews and personal communication are best cited in text or in notes – not in the bibliography. If an interview or correspondence is cited multiple times, use in-text citation (Scott, interview) and include a footnote with full citation at first mention.
Citations should include the names of both the person interviewed and the interviewer, brief identifying information, the place or date of the interview (or both, if known), and if a transcript or recording is available, where it may be found. Spell out ‘personal communication’ (when referring to email or other personal correspondence in text (Catherine Lamaison, personal communication.)
Use the McGill Guide. Suggested resource:
- v. Powley,  2 SCR 207.
- Arrange alphabetically by authors’ last names; for multiple entries, list chronologically placing the earliest work first.
- If an author has more than one entry in the References, use three em dashes: ———.
- Please provide full author name as published.
- List all materials (books, films, works of art) referenced in a single list of references.
- Date format for references: 11 June 2004.
(capitalize and italicize titles): McLuhan, Marshall. 1964. Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man. New York: Mentor.
Ncombwai, Numi. 1988. Epidemiology in Africa. Vol. 2. New York: Hershall & Son.
Schwarz, Henry and Sangeeta Ray, eds. 2000. A Companion to Postcolonial Studies. Oxford: Blackwell.
Smar, Ninian. 1976. The Religious Experience of Mankind. 2nd ed. New York: Scribnerʼs Sons.
Robbins, Bruce. 2000. “Race Gender, Class: Toward a New Humanistic Paradigm?” In A Companion to Postcolonial Studies, edited by Henry Schwarz and Sangeeta Ray, 556–74. Oxford: Blackwell.
Virilio, Paul. 1978. Speed and Politics, translated by Mark Polizzotti. New York: Semiotext(e).
Capitalize article titles; italicize journal names.
Peters, E. J. 1998. “Subversive Spaces: First Nations Women and the City in Canada.” Society and Space 16(6): 665–86.
Do not abbreviate journal titles
References to Films, DVDs or Video
Titles of films, videos and DVDs should be italicized and identified (in parentheses) by name of director(s) and year of release: Exotica. 1994. Directed by Atom Egoyan.
For DVD special editions, include date of release in parentheses. Additional information regarding DVD editions should be included in an endnote.
References to Electronic Sources
Follow the same format, name, title, place, date, online reference (see CMS 17, 15.7)
Weed, A.E. At the Foot of the Flatiron (American Mutoscope and Biograph Co., 1903), 35 mm film, from Library of Congress, The Life of a City: Early Films of New York, 1898–1906, MPEG video, 2:19 at 15 fps, http://www.loc.gov/item/00694378.
Use endnotes, or follow normal reference format in text and cite full URL in references; do not include date accessed. Titles of websites are generally set in roman without quotation marks and capitalized headline-style. Wikipedia can be treated as a website rather than as a conventional encyclopedia, with roman rather than italics for the title, eg:
“Wikipedia: Manual of Style,” Wikimedia Foundation, last modified April 7, 2016, 23:58, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Manual_of_Style.
City of Ithaca, New York (website), CivicPlus Content Management System, accessed April 6, 2016, http://www.cityofithaca.org/
Twitter and Social Media
Incorporate the facts into a footnote is possible; if not then include the citation information in the sentence.
- Garrett Kiely, Twitter post, September 14, 2011, 8:50 a.m. http://twitter.com/gkiely.
Contributions to electronic mail groups (listserves) should be identified by author, subject, name of group/listserve, email address, and date of message:
Newspapers and Magazines
Capitalize article titles, italicize newspaper name, provide URL but no access date for online articles.
Meikle, James. 2015. ‘Nearly 75% of Men and 65% of Women in UK to Be Overweight by 2030—Study.’ The Guardian, May 5, 2015.
Statistics Canada. 2001. 2002 Census Dictionary Reference, Catalogue No 92-378-XPE. Ottawa: Statistics Canada.
Hyphenation and Spelling
Hyphenation: follow Canadian Oxford Dictionary if term appears there; if not, use hyphen unless solid form is considered a ‘term of art’. Spelling dictionary is Canadian Oxford Dictionary.
The following are preferred:anglophone
Other (without any quote marks)
postcolonial, postmodern, postwar
Spell out whole numbers from one to ten, round numbers, and any number beginning a sentence. The same rules apply to ordinal numbers: second, fifty-fourth, thousandth; but 125th, 152nd.
French Usage in English Texts
Do not italicize French or foreign terms if they are familiar and in general use: recherché, oeuvre etc, otherwise they should be italicized
Spell city and country names in English (e.g., Montreal, Munich), unless it is important to use the original spelling (e.g. Montréal, München).
Use two-letter (postal) abbreviations for provinces and states: ON (not Ont.), MA (not Mass.). Do not use periods: the UK and the USA.
For italicized titles, punctuation marks are placed outside the italics command, unless they are part of the title.
Quotations are indicated by double inverted commas (“ ”); quotations within quotations are indicated by single inverted commas (‘ ’). Periods, commas, question marks and ellipses in quotations are placed inside the quotation marks.
Use single inverted commas only in a quotation: Jones writes, “In this case, ‘truth’ was a matter of opinion.”
Ellipses are indicated by three periods with spaces between them or on either side of them. A fourth period is added if the ellipsis ends the sentence: “Painting was forced, as it turned out, to offer us illusion . . .. Photography and cinema… satisfy, once and for all and in its very essence, our obsession with realism.”
No space is left between dashes and the preceding and following words: It was discussed— indeed, hotly debated—everywhere.
Use only an apostrophe to form the possessive of singular and plural nouns ending in s (the actors’ expressions) and nouns that are plural in form but singular in meaning (politics’ appeal, economics’ influence). Use an apostrophe to form the possessive of names ending in ‘s’ (eg. Peter Morris’ book) but an apostrophe and an ‘s’ in nouns ending with a double ‘s’ (a lass’s charms, the mass’s demands).
For emphasis, use italics; do not underline or use bold font. Use serial or Oxford comma.
The order of day, month, year should be consistent throughout the article: 20 June 1935.
Months should be spelled out and years designated in full: 10 March 2002, (not 10-03-02).
Decades may be indicated according to either of the following examples: the 1970s (without an apostrophe), the seventies.
It is the author’s responsibility to proofread the text carefully, as well as to verify the accuracy of titles, quotations and references, including accent marks and other diacritical markings for material in languages other than English.
Your abstract must be approximately 100–150 words and written in the language of the paper. It should be a brief summary of the key points of the article.
Following your abstract, include 5–8 keywords, which will enhance discoverability through TOPIA search engines, and databases.
Use a separate document for a short author’s bio of under 100 words and upload it separately to ScholarOne as “Supplementary – not for review”. Begin with your name in bold. For books, give date of publication only. This document will not be seen by reviewers.
Provide a copy of permission to use copyrighted material, if applicable. Permission can include a signed form, or a copy of an email or letter indicating permission from the copyright holder.
Please note that failure to include letters of permission to use copyrighted material will – at the very least – delay the publication of the article until the letters of permission have been received by the University of Toronto Press.
Figures should be included within the text upon initial submission. Once accepted for publication please remove the figures from the text and indicate exactly where each figure belongs. Keep the tables in the main file, but place them at the end of the file. Use the phrase “Figure 1 about here” in the approximate places where your figure should appear in the final copy.
Provide a separate EPS, JPEG, TIF, or PDF file in colour or black and white, as appropriate, for each figure (colour images preferred if possible for the online publication). All figures must have a minimum resolution of 300 dpi (600 dots per inch is preferred), or be at least 25 inches wide at 72 dpi. If you choose to submit figures (line drawings) produced in Adobe Illustrator, please “outline” the type prior to making the EPS files.
Authors are responsible for:
- providing images;
- providing captions;
- identifying where in the article the images should appear; and,
- acquiring necessary permission to use selected images.
Images should be the highest possible quality. Please remember that your computer screen is 72 dpi (dots per inch) while a printed journal like TOPIA is a minimum of 300 dpi. This means that an image that looks big on your screen will look 3 times smaller on the printed page.
You can check the number of pixels in your image by right clicking on the image (in the Explorer window on a Windows PC or using the Finder on a Mac) and selecting Properties (on a Windows PC) or Get Info (on a Mac).
The minimum we will accept is DVD frame grab quality: around 720 pixels (width) by 480 pixels (height) at 300 dpi.
Please provide captions in the text for all tables and figures. Once the manuscript is accepted for publication, you will be required to resubmit tables and figures as supplementary files with the appropriate captions on ScholarOne Manuscripts.
Upon manuscript acceptance, all authors must sign a copyright agreement.
“How to Alienate Your Editor: A Practical Guide for Established Authors”, written by Stephen K. Donovan and published in the Journal of Scholarly Publishing, is an excellent article on common mistakes made during the submission process.
Also useful is “Surviving Referees’ Reports” written by Brian Martin and also published in Journal of Scholarly Publishing.